|
|
|
Evaluating Web Sites
What you need to ask before using any web site:
1. Authority
- Who is responsible for the web site on which the web page resides?
- Are there any clues on the web page about the larger site?
- Look for a logo or icon that may be a link to the main web site.
- What is the background of the author of the web site?
- Is the author an expert in the field, a student or an organization?
- Has the author provided any information about herself and her
qualifications?
- Use search engines to try and find additional information about the
author's credentials.
- What is the focus or purpose of the organization?
- Look for any links to a description of the organization.
- Is there a way to contact the organization, company or person
responsible for the contents of the site?
- Is the name of the copyright holder given?
- Is the web site an educational site (.edu), a commercial site
(.com), a nonprofit organization (.org) or a government site (.gov)?
- Does the site list any recommendations or ratings from outside
sources?
2. Purpose and Objectivity
- Why has this information been posted and how objective is it?
- Is the point of view of the person or organization obvious?
- If there is advertising on the page, is it clear what relationship
exists between the author of the material and the advertiser?
- Is the purpose of the web site to inform or to broadcast an opinion?
- What audience is this web site trying to reach?
3. Content and coverage
- How comprehensive is the web site?
- Is there a large amount of information available or does the web
site consist primarily of links to other web pages?
- Is the information presented on the page consistent with your
knowledge of the topic?
- How accurate is the content of the page?
- Is the page free of grammatical and spelling errors?
- Are sources provided for facts so the information can be verified?
- Are references or bibliographies posted on the page?
- Is the source of the information stated or is a list of resources on
the topic provided?
4. Currency
- How current is the information?
- Web pages should state the date when they were created or updated.
- Are the links working and current?
- Does it state that it is an archival page?
|